PIZZA GARAGE

You can order from The Pizza Garage 3 ways: online, by phone, or in person.

1. ONLINE ORDERS:

ONLINE ORDERING IS OUR PREFERRED METHOD.

When you place an online order, you will receive two emails:

1. Your order confirmation — this confirms that we received your order.

2. Your pickup time confirmation — this confirms when your order will actually be ready for pickup.

PLEASE WATCH FOR THE SECOND EMAIL!

The pickup time you select when placing your order is a REQUEST, NOT A CONFIRMED PICKUP TIME. If we're especially busy or unable to accommodate your requested time, we may adjust it.

For the best selection and to help us accommodate your requested pickup time, we strongly recommend ordering 24 hours in advance.

2. PHONE ORDERS

You can also order by calling 585-355-4111 during business hours.

Please keep in mind that when we're busy, we may not be able to answer the phone or take phone orders as quickly as we can process online orders.

3. WALK-IN ORDERS

You're always welcome to stop in and place an order in person during business hours. 

We are proud to offer several different styles of pizza.

Below is a list of our day to day styles available in limited quantities:

New York

Detroit

Sicilian

Grandma

FULL MENU CAN BE FOUND HERE

Yes! Slices are available for both lunch and dinner. All slices are first come first serve until we sell out. You cannot pre-order slices online or over the phone, they are available for walk-in customers only. We offer slice combos and specials. Please note orders take precedence over slices. We do our best to have slices available throughout the day, and most days we do! However, when we are exceptionally busy with orders, we may not have slices available. 

New York Style pizza is a thin crust pizza that’s foldable and crispy. It was created for the busy lifestyle of New Yorkers who are always on the go.

There is only on-street parking. We are located at 1157 Culver Road. Please pay special attention to street parking signs. If you can’t find parking you can utilize the Covenant United Methodist Church parking lot (located off of Parsells Ave, we were granted permission). Please do not block any driveways, even momentarily!

"Peels on Wheels" currently does not have wheels, anymore anyway! Our truck is dormant and on display in the Pizza Garage. Please note we do not and will not partner with any third party delivery services.

We are takeout only, but there is a small bar-height table for casual dining. 

Yes, we offer gluten-free pizza options. While we take precautions, we cannot guarantee a 100% gluten-free environment, as there may be cross-contact with trace amounts of gluten.

Gluten-free whole round pizzas may be ordered the same day. However, gluten-free pan pizzas must be pre-ordered with a minimum of 24 hours’ notice and are not available for walk-in, same-day orders. We do not offer gluten-free slices.

Yes, we have some vegan options available. Take a peek at our menu to see what offer. Best way to stay up to date on vegan specials is to follow us on Instagram.

We get asked this question a lot and there are many parts to the answer as to why we choose not to. The main reason is, we’re dedicated to offering the best pizza we can to our community. Our sole focus is to provide an excellent experience through our pizza and service. It’s as simple as, we just love pizza! 

Unfortunately no, but maybe someday.  In the meantime, pick up a pie and take a short drive over to Three Heads Brewing with your pizza.

As of 2023, our truck is retired and permanently parked in the Pizza Garage. 

We can offer assistance with larger orders with advance notice. Please email us at contact@peelsonwheelspizza.com.

Please note we do not offer on site catering.

YES! We have gift cards available for in store purchases only (cannot be used for online ordering). Purchase in store.

We do not partner with any third party delivery services. Orders can only be placed directly with us or via our online ordering partner, ChowNow. Pickup is currently the only option. We have no plans to partner with any third parties for delivery services.